Fox News Digital Network

Fox News

Fox Business

uReport

Fox
News Radio

Fox News Latino

Fox Nation

Fox News Insider

Login

Account

You're logged in as

Profile

Logout

Search Site

Listen
to Fox News Radio Live›

On Air Now
›

On Air
Personalities ›

Home

Video

Politics

U.S.

Opinion

Entertainment

Tech

Science

Health

Travel

Lifestyle

World

Sports

On Air

Previous
Slide Next
Slide

Politics Home

Executive
Branch

U.S.
Senate

House of
Representatives

State
& Local

Courts

Pentagon

2012
Election Results

EPA accused of singling out conservative
groups, amid IRS scandal

By Eric Shawn

Published June 04, 2013

FoxNews.com

EPA
accused of political bias

EPA
accused of targeting conservatives amid IRS
scandal

It's not just the IRS.

A second federal agency is facing a probe and accusations of political bias
over its alleged targeting of conservative groups.

The allegations concern the Environmental Protection Agency, which is being
accused of trying to charge conservative groups fees while largely exempting
liberal groups. The fees applied to Freedom of Information Act requests --
allegedly, the EPA waived them for liberal groups far more often than it did for
conservative ones.

The allegations are under investigation by the House Energy and Commerce
Committee and the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, which is also
holding hearings on the Internal Revenue Service targeting of conservative
groups.

"I don't think it is fair at all. It is not fair to the American taxpayer --
the American taxpayer should expect and demand that the EPA treats everyone
equally in regard to these requests," said Pennsylvania Republican Rep. Tim
Murphy, a member of the Energy and Commerce Committee. "This cannot be
tolerated. As we see more federal agencies with this kind of bias, it is and
should be a concern for all of us."

Research by the Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI), a conservative
Washington, D.C., think tank, claims that the political bias is routine when it
comes to deciding which groups are charged fees. Christopher Horner, senior
fellow at CEI, said liberal groups have their fees for documents waived about 90
percent of the time, in contrast with conservative groups that it claims are
denied fee waivers about 90 percent of the time.

"The idea is to throw hurdles in our way," charged Horner, who says he
decided to look into the fee structure after the EPA repeatedly turned down his
group for waivers.

"In 20 cases of ours, since the beginning of last year, we were expressly
denied, or denied by them simply refusing to respond, in 18 out of 20 cases,"
said Horner, explaining that the batting percentage for fees waived in favor of
liberal groups is overwhelming.

"Earth Justice was batting 17 out of 19, the Sierra Club was the worst, at 70
percent granted, 11 out of 15. You add up some other groups and we found that 75
out of 82 groups granted, because these are the groups that the EPA has decided
are the favored groups."

The EPA has denied any favoritism.

Acting EPA Administrator Bob Perciasepe told the House Energy and Commerce
Committee on May 16 that "our policy is to treat everybody the same," and the
agency is considering pursuing an investigation.

In a statement to Fox News, the EPA said: "The Office of Inspector General
received from the Environmental Protection Agency the official request to look
into this matter just over a week ago, so the request is currently under review
by the OIG at this early stage."

But Horner, who has studied federal government agency practices as the author
of "The Liberal War on Transparency: Confessions of a Freedom of Information
'Criminal,'" says that charging fees or denying information requests is a
underhanded method that government agencies use to try and stymie the free flow
of information or political dissent.

"This is no different than denying a group that you don't agree with ...
whether you are the IRS or the EPA, their tax-exempt status," said
Horner.

"You're talking about essentially making or breaking them, or at a minimum,
snuffing out their ability to pursue their objectives."
Murphy said treating
groups differently is simply not right.

"We are hoping that the acting administrator of the EPA can already send a
message out to his people that this will not be tolerated," Murphy said. "It is
wrong. Similar with the people with the IRS who testified that, 'well some of
things may not be illegal,' they can still be wrong. People expect their
government to not be acting in these ways, but to be fair and just and truthful
in these informational quests and in their investigations."

Follow Eric Shawn on Twitter: #EricShawnonFox.

Print

Email

Share

Comments

Recommend

Tweet

Related Stories

Conservative
group claims it has proof IRS leaked donor list

Share This Article

View
Article

You must login to comment.

View
Article

Advertisement

Follow Fox News Politics

Get Our Free Newsletter

Newsletter Signup

Trending In Politics

1

IRS
worker blasts Lerner for blaming Ohio office on targeting, likens effort to
'nuclear strike'

2

Lawmakers
aim to rein in administration on data-collection 'dragnet,' change law

3

Red
light: Traffic cameras bring Ohio town to screeching halt

4

Democratic
senator calls for Holder to resign

5

Misfired
email tipped off DC officials to IRS scandal in 2010, earlier than previously
known

See all
trends›

View All Polls

Real Clear Politics Poll

Job Approval

Approve

Disapprove

Spread

Obama

47.5%

47.4%

+0.1%

Congress

14.4%

75.8%

-61.4%

Direction of Country

Right Direction

Wrong Track

Spread

RCP Average

32.4%

58.7%

-26.3%

Advertisement

Also on the web

FAIL: Yearbook Mistake IDs Student As 'Creepy Smile
Kid'

Man Has 22 Kids By 14 Women

WATCH: Bear Bears Arms, Bearly Breaks Into
Truck

WATCH: 'Jellyfish UFO' Caught On Tape Over Peru

DOE! Family Battles To Keep Pet Deer

Tepid: May Jobs +175k, Unemployment Up to 7.6%

Apple, Google, Facebook: Never Heard of PRISM

PRISM: 'They Quite Literally Can Watch Your Ideas
Form As You Type'

Government Storing Vast Phone, Email Data at NSA
Data Center in Utah

Misfired 2010 Email Alerted IRS Officials in
Washington of Targeting

Patriot Act's Author: Collecting Phone Data
'Un-American'

Francis: 'I Did Not Want to Be Pope'

Panama Bypass: China Gets OK for Nicaragua
Waterway

Poll: Most Say White House Hiding Something on
Benghazi

NY Times: Editorial Blasts Obama, Then Backs
Off

Sections

Home

Video

Politics

U.S.

Opinion

Entertainment

Tech

Science

Health

Travel

Lifestyle

World

Sports

Weather

Shows

America Live

America's
News HQ

America's
Newsroom

Cavuto

Fox
Files

Fox News
Sunday

Fox &
Friends First

Fox &
Friends

Fox &
Friends Weekend

Fox News
Watch

Fox
Report

Geraldo at
Large

Greta

Hannity

Happening Now

Huckabee

Justice with
Judge Jeanine

Red Eye w/
Gutfeld

Special Report

Specials

Studio B

The Cost of
Freedom

The Five

The Journal
Editorial Report

The O'
Reilly Factor

War
Stories

Tools

Live
Video

Trending

uReport

Newsletters

Alerts

Blogs

Mobile

Podcasts

Radio

Fox News Store

Apps &
Downloads

About

Careers

Internships -
FNCU

Fox
Around the World

Advertise With Us

Terms
of Use

Privacy Policy

Ad
Choices

Contact
Us

Email
Newsroom

FAQ

Media
Relations

Follow

Facebook

Twitter

Google+

LinkedIn

RSS

Newsletters

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or
redistributed. ©2013 FOX News Network, LLC. All rights reserved. All market
data delayed 20 minutes.